3 Comments
User's avatar
Patricia's avatar

The simple text of the Equal Rights Amendment, the battle to get it ratified by the states since 1923(!) and then Biden’s refusal to publish/have archivist certify it to become the 28th Amendment to the Constitution of the US tells you aaaaalllll you need to know about the “theater” that is women’s rights/women’s liberation in the United States.

unwarranted's avatar

If Karim is suppressing pangs of optimism, I think it’s actually in part the influence of Vanessa who, without expatiating, reminds those who pay attention, that MONEY is the god of the Caucasian people who must adopt a predatory countenance to protect themselves in the predatory world that they have created. “Don’t forget to get your carrying permit so you will always be protected.”

Another great discussion for which I am appreciative.

I think that it’s a shame that we rely on reducing states to their status as global players when discussing wars and ideology and entrenched conflicts. Dimitri and Vanessa did well to describe their experiences in a country that puts a premium on according humans their dignity., and that is readily apparent in how Iranians engage in conversation. That is revolutionary where I live.

Richard Wolff has outlined the structure of the capitalist society known as the USA, and it is literally a corporate system in which dignity has no value, and strips every individual of their ability to be whole, not in the economic sense, but in the human sense.. Who would ever vote for that?

I may be more defeatist than Karim because it is so easy to bomb bridges and blow up pipelines, and I fear that the mass slaughter of the Gulf States would be an invitation to the Zionists to form new terrorist states to hire millions of Jolanis to sow uncontainable chaos and destruction. This can’t happen presently, but Iran cannot remain on a war footing indefinitely, and the Zionists have time. Will causing a global economic depression

eliminate the power of the Zionists to control the West that sponsored their rise? I honestly have doubts. Perhaps the planet will only be spared if Trump goes full bore and Iran does as it has promised. A lot of people will be erased and more will be without any means. But my country will be altered if not ended, steeped in civil war. That would possibly make it worthwhile.

On the subject of information sovereignty, I think Karim is right. But I don’t think it is an almighty power of the West. The element of national, or racial pride is the place where consciousness can be nurtured and that is when awareness invariably follows. Just look at what Ibrahim Traore has accomplished in Burkina Faso. And he is only getting started.

In 2006, Martin Scorsese had a big hit with a movie called The Departed, starring Matt Damon and Jack Nicholson. It’s about a newly minted police officer in Boston who was a minion of a crime lord before he became a cop, and remained so as a cop. The plot is thickened by another young cop from the same first year class (Leonardo DiCaprio), whose existence and identity is secret, because he is working undercover in the same crime outfit that the crooked cop stealthily supports. The subterfuge is baked into the plot. And this is a good movie that has received acclaim.

But guess what. The Departed is a remake of an excellent Hong Kong film, with basically the same plot and all Chinese actors, or at least all Asian actors. It was on the market four years before The Departed, and it’s called Infernal Affairs.

Both the Chinese and the Koreans have some very accomplished filmmakers and performers. So I guess I am suggesting that states that nurture the arts can also promote awareness at the same time. Governments that actively create inducements for aspiring artists are governments worth defending. Both the British and the Americans have supported the arts in the past, and both have since left it to their oligarchs to gobble up.

And one thing that I wanted to touch on, I think the elimination of a viable left anywhere in the West is actually the result of 85 years of zero tolerance in America for any expression of an organized opposition to capitalism as a system.

Chomsky described this in several of his books, but it doesn’t reach enough brain cells.

Samuel Gompers was a London born American cigar vendor who founded the American Federation of Labor, which was an umbrella for many trade unions, and he made certain that socialism was not to be a goal or an option of unions. He died at a time when a good number of American workers were card carrying communists, but the union movement was in its infancy.

The Great Depression of 1929 and FDR and WWII comprised a perfect storm of pacification of the a nascent left, and when FDR died, the following president created the CIA and the NSA. As much as FDR had done to lift workers into a revived economy in which they had a stake, the power elites sought to have him assassinated or removed from office because he had extended too much opportunity to the dregs.

From the end of WWII, the corporate elites were massively invested in scaring the crap out of all Americans with regard to Russia and communism. School teachers were instructed to explain that the Russians were godless and predatory, and will try to seduce naive Americans to serve their ends. Teachers had their elementary school children crouch under their desks in case of a nuclear war. This actually went on all over the country.

First there was the drunk Senator from Wisconsin, who was allowed to make loud, obnoxious accusations against writers and actors in Hollywood for their left-leaning stories and movies. Joe McCarthy was a crazed anti communist who promised that America was teeming with communists. In addition to going after Hollywood, he went after members of the U.S. Army. The crime wasn’t his belligerence and rude bullying, and baseless claims. It was his ability to always have a camera recording his fits of rage, and his empowerment provided by his status as a Senator,

Then there was J. Edgar Hoover who did little to curb organized crime, as the head of the FBI, but he travelled the country warning everyone of the scourge of communism and the untrustworthiness of Russians.

So this criminal indoctrination of children goes a long way to explain why the U.S. is a dysfunctional society, and why our left isn’t left at all.

But here’s the thing. The educated classes of my country and European states, mostly regarded free speech as a universal right, and they were marginalized whenever speech was against the state, and they were easily bought off. For the intellectual in America, fair compensation was not available if you remained committed to telling the truth about America. And the truth is that the West is completely in line with lying as a policy. Diplomacy is a vast opportunity to impose your demands, but don’t negotiate. Tell your electorate and your audiences whatever you want, because lying is cost free. This is our Epstein era, and the truth is under threat like never before in the West.

But, Karim I don’t think that most Europeans were pummeled with the lies that Americans were. The Europeans embraced liberal education, and this is displayed in the existence of communist parties in many European countries.

Bob Martin's avatar

Beeley says at 17:50 that the transgender movement in the West is diminishing women's rights. That's news to me. Can you explain what she's talking about?