The Triumphalism Trap: How Anti-Imperialist Media Manufactures Its Own Consent

How the independent anti-imperialist media sphere reproduces the propaganda structures it was built to oppose.

We fully understand that not everyone can be a paid subscriber, but you can support us by restacking our work.

Manufacturing Counter-Consent

“In the name of socialism, usurping bureaucracies cut off from the people have achieved the pitiable wonder of transforming into a nightmare what humanity has for so long cherished as a dream.”

— Aimé Césaire, Letter to Maurice Thorez, 1956

There is a particular kind of intellectual dishonesty that only becomes visible over time. It is not visible in any single article, interview, or video, but in the accumulated shape of what has been said and, more importantly, what has never been said. Watch a media ecosystem long enough and its silences become as legible as its speech.

This essay is a critique of a media sphere I largely share political commitments with. I believe the critique of American empire, of NATO expansion, of sanctions regimes, of the credulous stenography that passes for foreign policy reporting in most Western outlets, is fundamentally …